| Platinum | Wonder Burger |
| Gold | Big O Burgers & Barbecue |
| Silver | Farmers Home Tavern |
| Silver | Tonys of Shields |
| Bronze | K-Walls Kitchen |
| Bronze | The Maple Grille Restaurant and Brewery |
| Top Pick | Culver's |
| Top Pick | Heck's Bar |
| Top Pick | Jen's Place |
| Top Pick | Scottish Inn |