| Platinum | Italia Cucina Familiare |
| Platinum | Tonys of Shields |
| Gold | Brooklyn Boyz Pizza |
| Gold | Olive Garden |
| Silver | G's Pizzeria & Deli |
| Bronze | daVinci's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Happy's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Milano's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Spencer's Route 46 |
| Top Pick | Tony's Original Restaurant |