| Platinum | Sombreros Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Marias Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | Coco Loco |
| Bronze | Cobb King |
| Top Pick | Don Felipe Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | El Rancho Grande |
| Top Pick | Poblano's Mexican Grill & Cantina |
| Top Pick | Rio Luna |
| Top Pick | Tamales Especial |
| Top Pick | Vargas & Sons Tortillas |