| Platinum | Jacks Fruit & Meat Markets Saginaw Locations |
| Gold | Bernthal Packing |
| Silver | Ted's Meat Market |
| Bronze | Nixon's Grocery |
| Top Pick | Jerky Joint |
| Top Pick | Kern's Sausages |
| Top Pick | Larry's Meat Market |
| Top Pick | Pat's Food Center and Do it Best Hardware |
| Top Pick | Romero Meat Market |
| Top Pick | Willi's Sausage |