| Platinum | Notch'Yo |
| Gold | Frosty's Freezer and Pizzaria |
| Silver | Jet's Pizza |
| Bronze | G's Pizzeria & Deli |
| Top Pick | Brooklyn Boyz Pizza |
| Top Pick | Dupuis Corner Bistro & Cafe |
| Top Pick | Hungry Howie's |
| Top Pick | Milano's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Old World Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Tiffany's Food & Spirits |