| Platinum | Tonys of Shields |
| Gold | Fuzzy's |
| Gold | Riverside Family Restaurant |
| Silver | Tim's Tonys Restaurant and Takeout |
| Bronze | Levi's Food & Spirits |
| Bronze | Miles Market |
| Top Pick | Artisan Urban Bistro |
| Top Pick | Bringer Inn |
| Top Pick | Noris Ham Cornbeef Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sullivan's Family Restaurant |