| Platinum | Mooney's Ice Cream and Cakes |
| Gold | Frosty's Freezer and Pizzaria |
| Silver | Cream and Sugar |
| Silver | Fuzzy's |
| Silver | Michigan Cream and Sugar |
| Bronze | The Freezer St. Charles, Mich |
| Bronze | Yogurt Yeti - Saginaw |
| Top Pick | Great Lakes Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Merrill Whippy Dip |
| Top Pick | Woody's Twisters |