| Platinum | Holeybody |
| Gold | Underground Railroad Resale |
| Silver | Nuechterlein's Jewelry |
| Bronze | Thrive Innovations |
| Top Pick | Bauer's Jewelry |
| Top Pick | Diamondjewelry Unlimited |
| Top Pick | Magma Gems |
| Top Pick | Purple Sage Bead Store |
| Top Pick | Saginaw Gold & Diamond Center |
| Top Pick | Stan's Goldmine Jewelry Store |